Blog Archives

Topic Archive: reasons aggregation

Computational Logic SeminarTuesday, March 1, 20162:00 pmGraduate Center, rm. 4422

Federico L.G. Faroldi

How (Not) To Aggregate Normative Reasons

Pisa-Florence/NYU/EPHE

Justification logic can be used to make sense of deontic modality, where justification terms are interpreted as normative reasons. Unlike proofs or epistemic evidence, which are (generally) factive, normative reasons must be ordered, since arguably one only ought to do just what one has most (more, stronger, etc) reason to do.

I make precise in what sense normative reasons are scalar, why an aggregation operation is needed, and introduce the most common types of scales. I then show that normative reasons cannot be (numerically) measured, and that the scale of normative reasons, if any, is therefore not ratio, interval, or ordinal (in a precise measurement-theoretic sense). I eventually discuss the consequences of these results for normative theorizing, and especially for normative particularism.